Reference Library - Peroxide Applications : Municipal Wastewater

ODOR CONTROL CHEMICAL

alternative technology summary

H2O2 vs. Iron Salts




H2O2 Iron Salts
Description Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a liquid product supplied as a 35% or 50% solution. It is available in containers of 50 or 300 gallons, or in bulk shipments of 500 - 20,000 gallons. Solid peroxide products (sodium percarbonate and calcium peroxide) are also available. Iron salts are supplied as liquid solutions containing 5-12% ferrous or ferric iron as either a chloride or sulfate salt. They are supplied in containers of 55 or 300 gallons, or in bulk shipments of 4,000 - 20,000 gallons.
Control Mechanism(s)
  • Oxidizes H2S
  • Retards septicity (adds dissolved oxygen)
  • Promotes bio-oxidation of organic odors
  • Ferrous salts precipitate H2S
  • Ferric salts may both oxidize and precipitate H2S
  • Chemical Reaction(s)
  • Neutral - Acid pH: H2S + H2O2 --> S + 2 H2O
  • Alkali: S2- + 2 O2 ----> SO42-
  • Prevention: 2 H2O2 ----> O2 + 2 H2O
  • Ferrous Salts: H2S + FeCl2 ----> FeS + 2HCl
  • Ferric Salts: 3 H2S + 2 FeCl3 ----> S + 2 FeS + 6 HCl
  • Dose Ratios (lbs Fe per lb-H2S)

    Neutral - Acid Alkali Prevention
    Theoretical 1.0 4.0 4.0
    Practical 1.2 - 1.5 4.5 - 5.0 2 - 8

    Ferrous Salts Ferric Salts
    Theoretical 1.7 1.1
    Practical 2 - 8 1.3 - 8
    Applications
  • Gravity mains (< 3-4 hours retention)
  • Force mains (< 1-2 hours retention)
  • Terminus of long retention force mains
  • Treatment plant headworks
  • Solids processing
  • Septage and leachate
  • Odor scrubbers
  • Ponds and lagoons
  • Gravity mains
  • Force mains
  • Anaerobic digesters
  • Solids processing units
  • Solids transfer lines
  • Advantages
  • High selectivity toward H2S
  • Adds dissolved oxygen to retard downstream septicity
  • Produces no harmful by-products
  • Extensive history of use
  • In-line nitrification and BOD reduction possible
  • Simple feed systems
  • Relative low feed rates (small storage tanks)
  • Extensive history of use
  • Simple feed systems
  • Effective for long-duration control
  • Can improve clarification processes
  • Assists in phosphate removal and struvite control
  • Not impacted by oxygen uptake rates
  • Disadvantages
  • High dosages are needed for control > 2 hours
  • Organic odors require bio-mediated oxidation
  • Reaction may take several minutes (without catalysis)
  • Oxidizer classification may restrict dosing sites
  • Removes dissolved oxygen from the water
  • Precipitate settles out in low-velocity sewers (< 2 fps)
  • Iron films form on pipe walls and instrument sensors
  • Ineffective for (non-sulfide) organic odors
  • Hard to achieve low sulfide limits (pH dependent)
  • Does not destroy sulfide (H2S may volatilize if the pH is lowered)
  • Product purity may impact biosolids re-use (heavy metal contamination)
  • Messy to handle
  • CERCLA rating may restrict dosing sites (persistent environmental hazard)
  • High dosages may cause solids carry-over from clarifiers
  • Solids production (> 3 lbs/lb - Sulfide) increases processing and disposal costs
  • Special Notes Hydrogen peroxide is one of the more rapidly growing alternatives due to its cost-effectiveness and environmental compatibility. Iron salts may be used synergistically with oxidants such as H2O2.


    See how this chemical compares to other chemicals in terms of:

  • Speed of reaction and duration of control
  • Costs
  • Storage hazards
  • Read more about Iron Salts




  • [Forward to Next Comparison]



    Home Email Us! Join Our Mailing List! Search What's New Links

    Copyright © H2O2.com