Reference Library - Peroxide Applications : Municipal Wastewater

ODOR CONTROL CHEMICAL

alternative technology summary

H2O2 vs. Potassium Permanganate




H2O2 Potassium Permanganate
Description Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a liquid product supplied as a 35% or 50% solution. It is available in containers of 50 or 300 gallons, or in bulk shipments of 500 - 20,000 gallons. Solid peroxide products (sodium percarbonate and calcium peroxide) are also available. Potassium permanganate (KMnO4) is a granular product available in a 25 or 50 kg pales, 4000 lb bins, and bulk deliveries of up to 40,000. A larger "nugget" product is available for solids blankets (clarifiers) and other slow-release applications.
Control Mechanism(s)
  • Oxidizes H2S
  • Retards septicity (adds dissolved oxygen)
  • Promotes bio-oxidation of organic odors
  • Oxidizes H2S and organic odors
  • Chemical Reaction(s)
  • Neutral - Acid pH: H2S + H2O2 --> S + 2 H2O
  • Alkali: S2- + 2 O2 ----> SO42-
  • Prevention: 2 H2O2 ----> O2 + 2 H2O
  • Neutral - Acid pH: 3 H2S + 2 KMnO4 ----> 3 S + 2 MnO2
  • Alkali: 3 S2- + 8 KMnO4 ----> 3 SO42- + 8 MnO2
  • Dose Ratios (lbs per lb-H2S)

    Neutral - Acid Alkali Prevention
    Theoretical 1.0 4.0 4.0
    Practical 1.2 - 1.5 4.5 - 5.0 2 - 8

    Neutral - Acid pH Alkali
    Theoretical 3.1 12.4
    Practical 4 - 5 12 - 15
    Applications
  • Gravity mains (< 3-4 hours retention)
  • Force mains (< 1-2 hours retention)
  • Terminus of long retention force mains
  • Treatment plant headworks
  • Solids processing
  • Septage and leachate
  • Odor scrubbers
  • Ponds and lagoons
  • Terminus of collection lines
  • Septage and leachate
  • Solids processing
  • Ponds and lagoons
  • Recycle streams
  • Advantages
  • High selectivity toward H2S
  • Adds dissolved oxygen to retard downstream septicity
  • Produces no harmful by-products
  • Extensive history of use
  • In-line nitrification and BOD reduction possible
  • Simple feed systems
  • Relative low feed rates (small storage tanks)
  • Fast reaction
  • Effective for organic odors
  • Disadvantages
  • High dosages are needed for control > 2 hours
  • Organic odors require bio-mediated oxidation
  • Reaction may take several minutes (without catalysis)
  • Oxidizer classification may restrict dosing sites
  • Relatively high cost
  • Labor intensive feed systems
  • Messy to handle
  • Provides no residual H2S control
  • Solids production is > 3 lbs/lb-Sulfide
  • Oxidizer classification may restrict feed sites
  • Special Notes Hydrogen peroxide is one of the more rapidly growing alternatives due to its cost-effectiveness and environmental compatibility. KMnO4 finds its widest use in solids processing where its fast reaction with organic odors is valued.


    See how this chemical compares to other chemicals in terms of:

  • Speed of reaction and duration of control
  • Costs
  • Storage hazards


  • [Forward to Next Comparison]



    Home Email Us! Join Our Mailing List! Search What's New Links

    Copyright © H2O2.com